Margaret Sanger | |||
---|---|---|---|
| |||
Born | September 14, 1879 Corning, New York | ||
Died | September 6, 1966 Tucson, Arizona[1] | ||
Spouse | William Sanger, James Noah H. Slee[1] |
Margaret Sanger (September 14, 1879 – September 6, 1966) was an American feminist and eugenics activist, who founded the American Birth Control League, which eventually became Planned Parenthood; she retired from the organization in 1940. She is commonly criticized for her legacy of antiblack racism.
Her main success was in bringing discussions of birth control into the public arena. She blamed large families for all of the ills of society,[2] and argued that a major reason to promote birth control was to stop abortions.[3] She was vigorously denounced by the Catholic Church because of her position on birth control.
As is common with progressives, Sanger believed that big government must have a role.[4]
Sanger was born on September 14, 1879 in Corning, New York as Margaret Louise Higgins[5] to Michael Hennessey Higgins and Anne Purcell Higgins.[6] Her brothers and sisters were: Ethel, Henry, John, Joseph, Lawrence, Mary, Nan, Richard, Robert, and Thomas.[7][8]
Among Sanger's siblings, her brother Robert("Bob") was a well known football player who was elected to the College Football Hall of Fame in 1954.[9] Her sister Ethel Higgins Byrne was a radical feminist activist like Margaret was.[10] When Margaret was nineteen years old, her mother Anne passed away from Tuberculosis at the age of fifty. But Margaret was already at this time blaming all of the problems of the world on overpopulation and large families. At the funeral, she exploded toward her father, blaming him for her death. "You caused this. Mother is dead from having too many children!"[11]
In 1896, she was enrolled in Claverack College and Hudson River Institute by her parents. Her tuition was initially paid for by two of her sisters.[12] As a young adult, Margaret attended nursing school at the White Plains Hospital in New York.[13]
During this time, in 1902, married William Sanger, who was an architect by trade.[14] Together, Margaret and William were active radicals in New York's Greenwich Village scene.[14][15] Bill Sanger was active in the Socialist Party of the Bronx.[16] They had three children together: Grant, Stuart, and Peggy. In 1903, after the birth of their first son, Margaret was diagnosed with Tuberculosis, the disease that had killed her own mother.[17] The Sangers waited five years for Margaret to recover from the disease before having their second and third children. Their daughter Peggy died young at the age of five from pneumonia.[18] Margaret became estranged from William in 1913.[19]
William, who was a radical like Margaret, was arrested in a sting operation for dispersing one of her pamphlets, Family Limitation,[20] for which he spent 30 days in jail. They divorced in 1921.
A year after her divorce from William Sanger, Margaret remarried to Noah Slee.[21] Like her first husband Bill, J. Noah was also of an activist mindset, helping Margaret achieve her objectives.
Her father Michael was an atheist and an outspoken Georgist activist. He had read Henry George's work Progress and Poverty and supported the Single Tax movement.[22] The influence of George was so profound in the Higgins family that one of Sanger's brothers was named Henry George McGlynn Higgins. This is significant in not only the obvious Henry George naming, but the second middle name of "McGlynn" is a reference to Edward McGlynn, a popular Catholic priest in New York who was excommunicated for his outspoken support of Georgist ideals.[23]
Her mother Anne had 18 pregnancies, with 11 of them being born.[24] In her autobiography, Sanger recalled that even as a child she blamed big families as the main reason for society's ills. She wrote:
Large families were associated with poverty, toil, unemployment, drunkenness, cruelty, fighting, jails; the small ones with cleanliness, leisure, freedom, light, space, sunshine.
The fathers of the small families owned their homes; the young-looking mothers had time to play croquet with their husbands in the evenings on the smooth lawns. Their clothes had style and charm, and the fragrance of perfume clung about them. They walked hand in hand on shopping expeditions with their children, who seemed positive in their right to live. To me the distinction between happiness and unhappiness in childhood was one of small families and of large families rather than of wealth and poverty.[25]
In her autobiography, Sanger lists the case of Sadie Sachs (a possibly fictional story) as having a deeply profound effect on her outlook.[26] According to the account, Sachs paid to have a backroom abortion for which the doctor botched the procedure. After recovering from an infection, Sachs consulted with the doctor as to how to how to prevent pregnancy and save her own life. The reply from the doctor was presumably that Jake, her husband, should be told to sleep on the roof.[27] Sadie became pregnant shortly after that, attempted to conduct a premature abortion on her own, and shortly died in the presence of Sanger.
After several years in Westchester, New York, Margaret and William Sanger's house at Hastings-on-Hudson was destroyed in a fire.[28] After the fire the house was rebuilt, but "A new spirit was awakening within me", and she began her new life as a social activist. When the Sangers moved to New York City, William went looking for work to sustain the family, but Margaret joined several socialist organizations and activities. In 1913 she joined the Women's Committee of the Socialist Party of New York,[29] and would eventually become a committee chair.[30]
Sanger argued for woman's liberation from the domination of men. She advocated economic independence and withdrawal from the traditional family unit, particularly marriage. She wrote “No woman can call herself free who does not own and control her body. No woman can call herself free until she can choose consciously whether she will or will not be a mother.” [31] (see self-realization). In 1911-1913, Sanger contributed articles for the New York Call, a socialist daily newspaper. Her columns were titled "What Every Mother Should Know" (1911–12) and "What Every Girl Should Know" (1912–13).[32][33]
During the time of William and Margaret Sanger's activist phase while living in Greenwich Village, she became involved with the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), befriending socialists, intellectuals, and left wing artists such as Mabel Dodge Luhan, John Reed, Upton Sinclair, and Emma Goldman. She also participated in strikes such as the 1912 Lawrence textile strike and the 1913 Paterson silk strike.[34][35] At the same time, the Greenwich bohemians were beginning to take up the cause of birth control, making them and the Sanger family natural allies.[36] Margaret would become a leader within the self-styled "Free Speech movement".[37]
Emma Goldman, Ezra Heywood, Moses Harman, D. M. Bennett, and other well known radicals of the "Free Speech League", like Margaret Sanger, sought to undermine and overturn the Comstock laws using subversive and demagogic means[38] in addition to their support for the cause of birth control.[39]
After being introduced to important members of the league such as Edward Bliss Foote and Theodore Schroeder, the league helped provide her with future legal assistance. The president of the league, Leonard D. Abbott,[40] and the league's attorney Gilbert E. Roe frequently acted as her lawyers during trial.[41]
In 1914, Sanger proved herself to be a radical's radical. While associated with the Free Speech League, she launched the magazine The Woman Rebel, which she new would provoke anti-obscenity laws such as the Comstock Law due to its (for the time) graphic sexual content.[42] Additionally, the magazine carried the slogan "No gods, no masters", which was a slight change from an IWW slogan: "No God, No Master."[43]
Seeking publicity for her cause, she sent seven issues of the Rebel through the mail before the Post Office finally responded. This led to the magazine being banned - an outcome she sought - and she was subsequently arrested.[44] She eventually was let out on bail and quickly fled the country.
While Sanger was overseas in exile, supportive radicals Emma Goldman and Ben Reitman continued distributing her pamphlet Family Limitation while conducting a nationwide speaking tour.[45]
After fleeing the country for England, Sanger met notable Fabian Socialists who helped her refine her craft. George Bernard Shaw, H. G. Wells, and Havelock Ellis, among others. Ellis in particular taught her to tone down her rhetoric. Ellis guided her to use a more cautious and prudent propaganda,[46] taking advantage of the language of social sciences but with a sharper emotional guile. She was also influenced by Neo-Malthusian writings. While in Europe, she met Charles Vickery Drysdale, who would go on to be a co-founder of the British Family Planning Association. While at a Fabian Society meeting, Sanger also met Marie Stopes, who, like Drysdale, was an early pioneer in the field of birth control. Stopes was also a Neo Malthusian. Stopes sought out Sanger's advice for her book Married Love.[47] Stopes considered Sanger to be an inspiration, and included a bit about contraception in the book.
A trip to Holland led Sanger to conclude that the fight for birth control would need to take on greater medical tones, instead of being a "free speech fight".[46] When she returned to America, she increasingly moved further away from her former radical friends, such as her former anarchist and communist friends in the IWW. Sanger explained: "I am determined to bide my time, consolidate my forces, continue my studies, my lectures, my letters to the countless women who are writing me every week."[46] Sanger had fully taken in the Fabian viewpoint of the Inevitability of Gradualness. She eventually developed the viewpoint that Marxism was nothing more than a fad religion, and wholly rejected it.[48]
Margaret Sanger and Otto Bobsein coined the term "birth control".[49][50] Before she returned to the States, Sanger was offered a position on the executive committee of the National Birth Control League (NBCL), the first birth control organization in the United States.[51] The NBCL was founded in 1915 by Mary Ware Dennett, Jessie Ashley, and Clara Gruening Stillman.[52]
In October 1916, Sanger opened and (illegally) operated the first birth control clinic in the United States, in Brooklyn, New York. It was raided by the police, and shut down. Sanger was sentenced to 30 days imprisonment for distributing contraceptives, which were illegal at the time.
In 1917, Sanger established the magazine Birth Control Review. In 1921, she founded the organization for which she would become most widely known - the American Birth Control League (ABCL).[53] Two years later, she founded the Clinical Research Bureau (CRB).[54] In 1929, as a result of differences between other leaders of the birth control movement, Sanger resigned her leadership position within the ABCL and assumed full control of the CRB.[55] At the same time, the CRB was renamed to the Birth Control Clinical Research Bureau (BCCRB).
In the mid-late 1920s, her husband Noah Slee began smuggling diaphragms into New York through Canada[56] in boxes labeled as 3-In-One Oil.[57] He later became the first legal manufacturer of diaphragms in the United States[58] beginning with his fifteen thousand dollar investment into Holland-Rantos(HR).[59] Behind the scenes,[60][61] Margaret was a major force for the creation of the company. The creation of HR also served another purpose, using free markets to legitimize her efforts. Early on in Sanger's activism, birth control items were primarily available through black market channels. The Slee's successfully reinvented it into a reputable, "capitalist business".[59] Herbert Simonds was a founding partner of Holland-Rantos.[62]
Working with the Urban League in 1929, Sanger opened up the first birth control clinic in Harlem, New York.[63] That same year, Sanger established the National Committee on Federal Legislation for Birth Control as a lobbying organization, in order to influence the creation and amendment of laws pertaining to abortion and birth control.[64] It was closed in 1937, only six months after the court case United States v. One Package of Japanese Pessaries.[65]
In 1936, Sanger met with Mahatma Gandhi while on a visit to India.[66] During their debate, Gandhi surprised her by rejecting her arguments. Gandhi was of the belief that love becomes lust if it is for the purpose of satisfaction. For Gandhi, men should endeavor to rise above animality and carnal satisfaction. He opposed artificial birth control and preached abstinence.[66]
During her tenure as leader of the birth control movement, Sanger was very adept at gaining the support of wealthy donors. In 1924 and again in 1925, John D. Rockefeller Jr. donated five thousand dollars to the ABCL.[67] Others she frequently associated with were Mary Lasker, who became wealthy from her husband's advertisements in the tobacco industry; Clarence Gamble, heir to the Procter and Gamble company;[68] and Katherine McCormick, heir to the McCormick fortune.
After the resolution of differences a decade earlier, the BCCRB and the ABCL merged in 1938 to form the short-lived Birth Control Federation of America.[69] The organization changed it's name to Planned Parenthood in 1942.
When the organization changed its name to Planned Parenthood, Sanger was very displeased. Even in the smallest degree, it potentially encourages having more children.[70] She wrote:
It irks my very soul and all that is Irish in me to acquiesce to the appeasement group that is so prevalent in our beloved organization.
She believed that some people should be 100% barred from procreation of any kind, rather than limited encouragement that could produce the wrong kind of people, if, albeit, less of them.[71] She said as much, in a video that surfaced in 2014 from a 1947 One Minute News interview she was in with John Parsons of British Pathé. In the footage, she called for a 10-year ban on babies, insisting that it is both practical and humane.[72][73][74] She again made similar comments in 1957 in an interview with Mike Wallace of ABC. Wallace asked her if she believed in the existence of sin and her response was that "I think the greatest sin in the world is bringing children into the world" - and after a few second uncomfortable pause she said "that have disease from their parents, that have no chance in the world to be a human being practically. Delinquents, prisoners, all sorts of things, just marked when they’re born. That, to me, is the greatest sin that people can commit."[75] At other times, she called for sterilization, a baby code, and a better distribution of babies.[76]
During the 1950s, Sanger worked with Katharine McCormick to fund the research being conducted by Gregory Pincus to develop The pill. A few years later, Enovid was the first birth control formulation submitted for FDA approval.[77]
Over time, Sanger increasingly wanted to work on an international level. Sanger worked to spread her work in Japan, through her contact with Shidzue Katō.[78] She made an impact in China, working with Pearl Buck to establish a clinic in Shanghai.[79] And in 1953, she established in India the International Planned Parenthood Committee, which would become the International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF).[80] C. P. Blacker, a prominent eugenist, was the first administrative chairman of the IPPF.[81]
For a more detailed treatment, see Malthusianism.
Sanger was a believer in the doctrines of Robert Malthus, and early on, this caused problems for her newly formed magazine.[82] She frequently wrote that too much population was the cause of unemployment, poverty, crime, and war, and she would often issue challenges to people to provide realistic solutions to overpopulation.[83]
In 1925, she organized the Sixth International Neo-Malthusian and Birth-Control Conference together with the American Birth Control League.[84][85] In 1927, encouraged by George Bernard Shaw and H. G. Wells,[86] she organized the first World Population Conference in Geneva.[87]
Margaret Sanger campaigned for eugenic controls to enforce what she called "race hygiene" and was a member of the American Eugenics Society and the English Eugenics Society.[88][89][90]
Many modern ideas of the substandard morals and inferiority of particular races are echoed in Sanger's writings. She wrote in one of her "What Every Girl Should Know" commentaries, that aboriginal Australians are in her opinion "the lowest known species of the human family, just a step higher than the chimpanzee in brain development," and that they possess "so little sexual control that police authority alone prevents him from obtaining sexual satisfaction on the streets." She compared these aborigines to "normal man and Woman" who have demonstrated control over their sexual desires.[91] She had a very deep hatred for other races that demonstrated a greater fecundity, such as the Chinese and the aborigines.
Additionally, she wrote about the failure of traditional ethics in sexuality that "... have in the past revealed their woeful inability to prevent the sexual and racial chaos into which the world has today drifted."[92]
Margaret Sanger associated with racists[93] and even held a close personal relationship with klansman and Nazi sympathizer Lothrop Stoddard, co-founding the American Birth Control League along with him and a few others. In 1926, she was the guest speaker at a Ku Klux Klan rally in Silverlake, New Jersey.[94] Despite these and many other things, her views on race have been intensely debated over the years. One Sanger biographer even wrote that "Margaret Sanger was never herself a racist, but she lived in a profoundly bigoted society, and her failure to repudiate prejudice - especially when it was manifest among proponents of her cause - has haunted her ever since."[95]
According to the Margaret Sanger Papers Project, Sanger conducted "a series of affairs with several men, including Havelock Ellis and H.G. Wells".[96] Her affair with H. G. Wells[97] is probably the most well known, however she is also known to have had affairs with Herbert Simonds,[98] Harold Hersey,[99] Lorenzo Portet,[100] Harold Child,[101][102] Hugh de Selincourt,[103] and Angus Macdonald.[104]
Her affair with Havelock Ellis probably had the most immediate devastating effect. Sanger first met Ellis in December 1914, and just a few weeks later they were sending each other passionate letters.[105] One letter read "I still love all that I have loved, and even if I loved another I should still love you". Ellis' wife Edith was on a speaking tour in America when Havelock mentioned Margaret to her in correspondence. Edith suffered both a physical and nervous breakdown and returned to England.
She passed away the following year.[105]
Sanger died in Tucson, Arizona on September 6, 1966,[1] of complications from congestive heart failure.[106] She was 86 years old.[107] She is buried in the prestigious Green-Wood Cemetery in Sunset Park, Brooklyn.[108]
Planned Parenthood annually gives awards to those who support them and the top award they give is called The Margaret Sanger Award.[109][110] Alan Guttmacher, who was a President of Planned Parenthood from 1962 to 1974 and who was also former Vice-President of the American Eugenics Society,[111][112] stated: "We are merely walking down the path that Ms. Sanger has carved out for us." [113][114] Similarly, Faye Wattleton, who was the president of Planned Parenthood until 1992, stated that she was "proud" to be "walking in the footsteps" of Margaret Sanger.[114] In 1960, Sanger was nominated for a Nobel Peace Prize.[115]
Dr. William Moulton Marston developed the character Wonder Woman through his inspiration of Sanger.[116]
A request was sent to the Smithsonian Institution for a bust of Sanger currently on display in a "Struggle for Justice" exhibit. The bust was a gift of Cordelia Scaife May.[117] The request, led by a group of Black pastors, noted that Sanger has previously spoke in front of the KKK, as well as a long line of racist viewpoints.[118][119][120] One reason the Smithsonian refused the request was because of her role in Women's rights. The pastors noted that it would make more sense to place the bust in an exhibit together with "with busts of Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler, Stalin, Mao Zedong, Goebbels, Pol Pot, and Dr. Mengle," in order to "put her in proper historical context with the infamous and evil figures who committed genocide."[121]
Overshadowed by her well known activism in the arena of birth control and the organization Planned Parenthood, is Sanger's support for Euthanasia. During the 1950s, Sanger was a member of the advisory council for the Euthanasia Society of America.[122]
On April 20, 2016, US Treasury secretary Jack Lew announced that Harriet Tubman would replace Andrew Jackson on the front of the $20 bill,[123] for which Margaret Sanger was a contender.[124]
The Planned Parenthood of Greater New York announced in July that they would rename their headquarters, due to Sanger's racism and promotion of eugenics.[125] In a statement, they said: "Margaret Sanger's concerns and advocacy for reproductive health have been clearly documented, but so too has her racist legacy."
In her book The Case for Birth Control, quoting approvingly of Havelock Ellis:[141]